Commentaries
|
 Infanticide The Deadly Logic of Abortion in CourtWhen a Canadian woman strangled her newborn, the jury said it was murder. But the judge had other ideas. Listen Now | Download
In April 2005, Katrina Effert, age nineteen, secretly gave birth to a baby boy in the downstairs bathroom. She then strangled the child, wrapped him in towels, and dropped him over the backyard fence behind a neighbor’s shed. After repeatedly lying to police and trying to pin the crime on a man she hooked up with nine months earlier, Effert finally confessed to killing the child, whom she named Rodney. In 2006 and again in 2009 juries convicted her of second-degree murder with a minimum of ten years in prison. Earlier this month the same judge who presided over Effert’s trial in 2009 changed the conviction to infanticide and sentenced her to a three-year suspended sentence with probation. In England since 1922 and in Canada since 1948, infanticide has been separated from murder. Women who killed their newborns were often domestic servants who hid their pregnancies and destroyed the evidence for fear of being fired. Juries were unwilling to convict those women of murder since it carried the death penalty. Therefore, a new crime with a lesser penalty was created using the dubious assumption that only a mentally disturbed and, thus, morally irresponsible woman would kill her own child. Mental illness, remember, is the way that secular societies replace the judgmental “sin” word. According to an article in Canada’s National Post, when Justice Joanne Veit gave instructions to the jury in 2009, she told them that if they determined that Efferts was “disturbed” — a word that has no clear legal or psychological definition — they had to find her guilty of infanticide. The jury nonetheless returned a verdict of murder. Now whether or not Veit should have overturned the jury’s decision can be debated. What can’t be debated was the judge's chilling rationale. Veit linked her leniency and Effert’s crime to abortion. Canada, you see, has no restrictions on abortion. If Effert had had an abortion the day before she delivered, all would be well — legally at least. Instead she gave birth. As reported in the Calgary Herald, Veit wrote that the lack of a Canadian abortion law shows that “many Canadians… generally understand, accept and sympathize with” hard-pressed mothers, “especially mothers without support.” So, such sympathy makes infanticide permissible? Commentator Mark Steyn correctly states that the judge is, in essence, justifying “fourth-trimester abortion.” He goes on: “So a superior court judge in a relatively civilized jurisdiction is happy to extend the principles underlying legalized abortion in order to mitigate the killing of a legal person — that’s to say, someone who has managed to make it to the post-fetal stage.” As Dr. Al Mohler puts it, “The willingness to kill within the womb leads logically to a willingness to kill outside the womb.” Of course it does — and don’t let abortion supporters deny it. Princeton Professor Peter Singer has made that argument for years as a justification for killing infants. At least this case in Canada exposes where the evil logic of abortion leads. It is totally morally unsustainable. But it’s clear that despite the fact that more and more Americans at least are turning pro-life, the battle is far from over. We, that is, the Church, have a lot of work to do to uphold the dignity — and the sacredness — of every human life, from conception to natural death.Further Reading and Information
The verdict on Katrina Effert Fourth Trimester Abortion R. Albert Mohler | Christian Post | September 17, 2011 A Baby’s Life Must Be Worth More than This Susan Martinuk | Calgary Herald | September 15, 2011 Abortion to Infanticide Kim Moreland | BreakPoint.org | September 14, 2011 |
Discover more: Search our family of websites.
PRINT
RSS
Comments:
The Sina sporting events Xun 15:Double zero about March 31 Peking occasion, 2012 match Any category match within quarter pleasant the final spherical to address away.The particular FC master industry throughout Chongqing squareds Chengdu to thank slender allied.1st 50 % field game, large foot foreign support radicle Lun doorway ahead of get in order to take to break an aid house team 1-0 major.Better half field, The european union sunshine compacted snow and also radicle Lun will be once more weighty the particular foot hook up in to about three balls, end FC throughout Chongqing head of the family discipline 4-0 great triumph Chengdus say thanks to thin allied. The 13th min's, hefty ft . the still left path cheap nike shoesWholesale Converse Shoes involving part of group, Li Supposrr que Yuan, distributes throughout, the radicle Lun is actually forbiding to obtain in order to blast to get rid of a new front door within the area, is sufficient 1-0 top give thanks to slender allied.The twentieth mins, heavy the actual foot swiftly counter-attack, sun excellent skiing conditions in The european countries via make offensive remaining way to acquire soccer ball they are driving directly, the particular Li Fei gives guidance the former to distributed moderate the actual basketball sea food leap blunt crest, the particular ball is simply a minor attracted to.First 50 percent discipline online game, weighty foot 1-0 leading always be more than. The second half area game simply started for just two moments as well as assessed ample end up being and then extended a new report by simply sun excellent skiing conditions inside European countries.Du Yu's forbiding a far firing from the area outside is actually obstructed, sun snow inside The european union maintains which has a dozens of regarding entrance golf balls to penetrate, heavy foot 2-0 primary Chengdu.The 58th minutes, heavy the particular base unusual assist radicle Lun go into one particular ball yet again, rewrite in order to 3-0 in credit score associated with industry.The 66th minutes, Mummy Xiao Lei fails another get together rearguard, analyzing ft . Three folks is much more anti- achievement.Ma Xiao Lei goes by basketball sunlight compacted snow in The european countries beside body, the second increases ft to shoot ball in aim basketball to enter, hefty feet 4-0 far away leading. Finally, with this Chuan Yu conflict in, large ft . from master discipline along with 4-0 conquer Chengdu by way of thanking slender allied, ended this particular complement a fantastic success regarding 1 / 4 of most video games. FC go throughout Chongqing delivers look:5-Li Cuando Yuan, 9-radicle Lun, 10-Li Fei, 14-Europe sunshine snow, 32-Ma Xiao Lei, 33-bright celestial body overhead Guo, 17-Xiao quake, 19-Chen Long Yuan, 13-Meng Wei, 30-Teng still Kun, 11-Du Yu with regard to repair visual appeal:12-Wang Sheng, 23-national prestige, 36-Zheng Wei, 7-Xu Qing, 8-the Zou Yu grow to be, 21-beard Xiao feather, 28-the chapter Age bracket head hair visual appeal throughout Chengdu:1-Zhang Chen, 2-Ping Zhuo Yi, 6-Wang Kai, 7-, Gao Xiang, 8-Yang Hao, 16-Wang Cun, 23-Yang They, 27-Yang Opleve Zhi, 28-Fan Pei Pei, 4-Yang Ting, 32-the Zou pay a visit to(Chi Lin)