Has the Time Come?

Hobby Lobby and the HHS Mandate


Why has a major retailer decided to defy a federal mandate? The owners are Christians, and they’ve decided to obey God first. Stay tuned to BreakPoint.

Listen Now | Download

John Stonestreet

Earlier this month, Hobby Lobby, a Christian-owned arts-and-crafts retailer with 500 stores and 13,000 employees nationwide, announced that it would not comply with the HHS mandate.

By doing so, the company has subjected itself to fines that could amount to a staggering $1.3 million a day.

Chuck Colson warned that the day would come when Christians would have to choose between the dictates of their faith and obeying the government.

And he was right.

As we’ve previously described on Breakpoint, the HHS mandate forces employers to fully subsidize services for their employees that, for many, violate deeply held convictions. Although the media has chosen to focus exclusively on the contraception side of the mandate, under the regulations, employers must also provide coverage for sterilization and abortifacients, such as Plan B, the “morning-after pill,” and Ella, the so-called “week after pill.”

Paying for these abortion-inducing drugs is what Hobby Lobby’s owners, the Green family, object to. They’ve endeavored to run their business on Christian principles, including Sunday closures, treating employees fairly, and honoring the sanctity of life. Paying for abortifacients definitely violates those principles.

So they filed a lawsuit against HHS but, unlike plaintiffs in ten other cases, including other businesses, they were denied an injunction. While appealing the denial, they had to choose between complying with the law or refusing to comply and accepting the consequences.  To their credit, they’ve chosen the latter.

But what do we need to know in light of this? Well, given the trajectory of our culture, the kind of choice the Green family was forced to make is inevitable for the rest of us too, regardless of who occupies the White House or controls Congress. This was spelled out in the Manhattan Declaration. When it spoke of the “decline in respect for religious values” in the law, it anticipated that non-compliance may be required of those of us who claim Christ.

For Hobby Lobby, that time has come. It may be the first Christian-run institution to choose non-compliance with the HHS mandate, but barring a change in the law, it won’t be the last. This weekend, we’re offering a full update on the issue on BreakPoint this Week. The show features Matt Bowman from the Alliance Defending Freedom and Emily Hardman of the Beckett Fund. Listen on radio, or by coming to BreakPoint.org and clicking on this commentary.

But let’s be clear: non-compliance won’t be limited to the HHS mandate. This is the post-Christian America that Francis Schaeffer, Chuck Colson and many others predicted. For many—not all, but many American Christians, this is new and unsettling territory. We’ve become used to a society that, while officially non-sectarian, paid homage to most of their beliefs and values, even if it didn’t always live by them.

As Alexis de Tocqueville put it, “Americans combine the notions of Christianity and of liberty so intimately in their minds, that it is impossible to make them conceive the one without the other.”

This has made choosing between God and Caesar unnecessary, unless, as the struggles of the Civil Rights movement showed, you were African-American.

One of the consequences of this close identification was that, for many American Christians, our sense of identity was more shaped by our nation than by our place in the body of Christ. We conceived of ourselves as Christian Americans instead of American Christians.

Now this is in the process of changing. It’s challenging, even painful. And let me be clear: We’re not to give up on America by any stretch of the imagination. I’ve heard far too much despair from Christians since November, as if the Kingdom of God was dependent on the American ballot box.

We’re called to live faithfully and courageously today; to love our neighbor and our country. And the best way to do that is to remember that we first and foremost belong to Christ. And therein, and only therein, lies the hope that gives us the courage for the tough decisions ahead.
Further Reading and Information

Update: John Stonestreet Interviews Legal Experts in the Hobby Lobby Case for BreakPoint This Week (24 minute format).

Chuck Colson's Two-Minute Warning on HHS and civil disobedience: "The Time is Now"
(Note this video came out after the mandate appeared and has over 42,000 views).

Colson Center HHS issues section (including posts on Hobby Lobby's decision to disobey).

Becket Fund

Letter to Diognetus

Manhattan Declaration


Which came first, the chicken or the egg on my fac
As my subject implies, this is very embarrassing. I have no way to tell whether the reference to "The Time Is Now" under "FURTHER READING AND INFORMATION" above was there when I posted my earlier comment or not. I downloaded a copy of this page after I noticed that my comment had been published, apparently about 5 hours after I posted it, and in that copy it is there. Perhaps it was put there during those 5 hours as a result of someone on the webmaster staff reading my comment. But it is also possible that it was already there before I posted it. If I had noticed that I obviously would have mentioned it in my comment. I would have said something like, "He announced that it had come, in the 2-Minute Warning message listed on this very page under FURTHER READING AND INFORMATION." As it is I look like an idiot. I will try to be more attentive in the future, Lord willing.
The late great Chuck Colson didn't just warn that the time would come, Mr. Stonestreet. He announced that it had come, in the 2-Minute Warning message of this past February 7th, titled, oddly enough, "The Time Is Now". It's still available at www.colsoncenter.org.