An ethical dilemma arose this weekend when popular website Jezebel published the names of teenagers who had tweeted ugly racist remarks about President Obama (having first contacted administrators at the teens' schools). Slate columnist Katy Waldman
ponders whether it's ever right to publicize the names and actions of minors, no matter how shameful those actions are.
Comments:
What, exactly, are the schools supposed to do with this information? I dislike racism, but I'm also not crazy about forcible indoctrination. Even if they can get the kids to SAY the right things, it doesn't change what's in their hearts. And any consequences they face would simply make them martyrs. (A bigger question is why the schools would be able to impose consequences anyway.)
The possibility that this could have a long-term negative impact on the lives of these kids should make us all shudder. I think most of us could look back on some bad things we've done in the past and be thankful we were allowed to leave them behind.
On the other hand, immunity for trolls is a rather distasteful thing.